Rapid expansion is a sign of success, but for multi-state medical practices, it can also create serious legal exposure. When growth strains financial operations, payroll is often the first obligation to slip. In many states, even a single missed pay cycle can expose practice owners to steep penalties, backpay liability, and personal criminal liability. The New Jersey Department of Labor is reportedly investigating complaints that a privately owned dermatology practice with over 30 offices across New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Florida has missed multiple payroll cycles. Staff, including nurse practitioners and physician assistants, have gone months without pay, as the practice’s rapid expansion appears to have outpaced its ability to meet payroll and other financial obligations. This alert highlights the key legal considerations for physician-owners navigating wage payment obligations in multi-state healthcare operations.
Legal Landscape
Both New Jersey and Pennsylvania law require employers to pay wages on regular, pre-established paydays. The New Jersey Wage Payment Law, N.J.S.A. 34:11-4.1, et seq. (NJWPL), requires employers to pay the full amount of wages due to employees at least twice during the calendar month on regular paydays designated in advance. Each regular payday must be no more than 10 working days after the end of the pay period for which payment is made. Violations of the NJWPL can expose employers to liability for the full amount of unpaid wages plus significant statutory penalties, which may include liquidated damages of up to 200%, and attorneys’ fees. Employers should also be aware that there criminal penalties can be assessed to principals, owners, managing members, and corporate officers for willful violations of the NJWPL, where they knowingly or intentionally failed to pay wages in accordance with the law, rather than through mere inadvertence or a good-faith dispute.
In Pennsylvania, the Wage Payment and Collection Law (PAWPCL), 43 P.S. § 260.1, et seq., similarly requires employers to pay all wages due on regular paydays designated in advance by the employer. Employers must pay wages no later than the regularly scheduled payday for the pay period in which the wages were earned. If an employer is found to have violated the PAWPCL, employees may recover the full amount of unpaid wages plus liquidated damages of 25% of the total wages due, as well as reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. As with the NJWPL, willful violations of the PAWPCL may result in criminal penalties, including fines and imprisonment.
New York’s Labor Law §§ 190–199-a, by way of further example, requires timely payment of wages on established pay days, with penalties including liquidated damages of 100% of unpaid wages, civil penalties, and potential criminal liability for willful violations. Delaware’s Wage Payment and Collection Act, 19 Del. C. § 1101 et seq., similarly mandates regular payment of wages and authorizes liquidated damages and administrative penalties for noncompliance.
Other states, such as Florida, notably, do not have a comprehensive state wage payment statute. This distinction can create a false sense of security for employers who assume the absence of a state statute means reduced risk. Employers operating across multiple jurisdictions should ensure compliance with each state’s specific requirements, as obligations and penalties vary significantly.
What Employers Should Do Now
If your organization is experiencing payroll difficulties, consider taking the following steps.
- Communicate proactively with employees. Transparency about payroll delays can help preserve trust and reduce the risk of complaints being filed with state labor agencies.
- Consult with employment counsel immediately. An attorney can help assess your obligations under applicable state wage payment laws, develop a remediation plan, and mitigate exposure to statutory penalties, liquidated damages, and potential criminal liability.
- Review multi-state compliance. Employers with operations in multiple states should audit their payroll practices to ensure compliance with each jurisdiction’s wage payment requirements, including pay frequency, timing, and recordkeeping obligations.
Physician-owners should be aware that employees who have missed or delayed paychecks may also consult with counsel or the local department of labor and bring legal claims, potentially entitling them to not only the unpaid wages but also penalties and awards of interest, liquidated damages, and attorneys’ fees.
How to Remain Compliant: What Physician-Owners Should Watch For:
Physician-owners should monitor for the following warning signs that payroll compliance may be at risk:
- Rapid expansion straining available cash flow or credit facilities
- Billing and collections backlogs that delay revenue realization
- Over-reliance on a single payer or narrow payer mix
- Management company or MSO arrangements where payroll responsibility is unclear or delegated without adequate oversight
- Frequent turnover in bookkeeping or financial management personnel
Whether you are an employer navigating payroll compliance challenges or an employee who has experienced missed or delayed wages, reach out to Christopher Mayer or Tina Segreto at Frier Levitt to discuss your options.
General Counsel
Associate
