As states continue to enact legislation aimed at increasing oversight of pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs), legal challenges are complicating efforts to regulate the industry. PBMs are increasingly challenging state laws under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), arguing that federal law preempts certain state regulations. While courts have generally upheld laws addressing pharmacy reimbursement and PBM pricing practices, provisions governing pharmacy networks, patient steering, and benefit design have faced greater legal obstacles. These mixed rulings highlight the ongoing tension between state efforts to strengthen PBM oversight and federal protections governing employer-sponsored health plans.
A.J. Barbarito provided insight to Modern Healthcare into the legal challenges facing state PBM reforms, particularly laws requiring PBMs to accept willing pharmacies into their networks and prohibiting PBMs from steering patients toward affiliated pharmacies. As courts continue to limit certain state regulatory efforts, lawmakers are exploring more aggressive approaches, including legislation targeting vertically integrated PBM and pharmacy businesses. Addressing the potential for broader federal action, A.J. noted:
“If there’s not some breathing room made here within ERISA and health plan regulation, it seems there may be some bipartisan appetite for actually breaking these companies up.”
Senior Associate