Frier Levitt Successfully Overturns More Than 99% of PBM Audit Findings for Dispensing Physician Practice

Harini Bupathi and Mariaeva Batlle

Results

Frier Levitt recently represented an Arizona-based oncology practice in successfully challenging audit findings issued by a major pharmacy benefit manager (PBM), securing the reversal of more than 99% of the amount at issue. Following a desk audit, the PBM identified more than $200,000 in alleged discrepancies. Through Frier Levitt’s representation and subsequent appeal, the PBM overturned all but one discrepancy, reducing the amount at issue to just $1,500.

PBM Audit Findings Against a Dispensing Physician Practice

Unlike traditional retail or specialty pharmacies, dispensing physician practices prescribe and dispense medications directly to patients under their care. While these practices operate differently from traditional pharmacies, they may nevertheless be subject to the same stringent PBM audit requirements and documentation standards under their applicable PBM agreements.

In this matter, the PBM identified numerous discrepancies involving allegedly missing prescription records and insufficient proof of medication receipt or delivery. The findings placed more than $200,000 at issue, despite the practice’s direct involvement in prescribing and dispensing medications to its patients.

Frier Levitt’s Successful Appeal

Frier Levitt worked closely with the practice to prepare and submit a comprehensive PBM audit appeal challenging the alleged discrepancies. In addition to relying on applicable Arizona fair audit protections, our attorneys emphasized the practice’s unique role as both prescriber and dispenser and the importance of evaluating supporting documentation in the context of its dispensing operations. The PBM’s audit review committee ultimately reversed nearly all disputed findings, demonstrating the importance of a well-supported, practice-specific approach to challenging PBM audit determinations.

Key Takeaways for Dispensing Physician Practices

This outcome highlights the significant financial exposure that dispensing physician practices, like traditional pharmacies, may face from PBM audits. However, the unique nature of physician dispensing operations may present important considerations when evaluating and challenging PBM audit discrepancies.

Dispensing physician practices should take proactive steps to minimize audit exposure and protect their rights when challenging adverse PBM findings. Key considerations include:

Maintain Thorough Documentation:

Keep accurate and complete prescription, dispensing, and medication receipt or delivery records to support compliance with applicable PBM requirements.

Understand Applicable PBM Requirements:

Review PBM contracts, audit protocols, and relevant state laws, including applicable fair audit protections, to understand documentation obligations and available appeal rights.

Carefully Evaluate Audit Findings:

Review each alleged discrepancy to identify potential errors, unsupported findings, or circumstances unique to physician dispensing operations.

Act Promptly to Preserve Appeal Rights:

Pay close attention to audit response deadlines and appeal procedures to avoid forfeiting opportunities to challenge findings.

Develop a Comprehensive Appeal Strategy:

Present supporting documentation and arguments that account for the practice’s dispensing operations, applicable PBM requirements, and relevant legal protections.

As demonstrated by this matter, a well-supported appeal that considers the unique operations of a dispensing physician practice can be critical to overturning adverse audit findings and reducing potential recoupment demands.

How Frier Levitt Can Help

Frier Levitt represents pharmacies and dispensing physician practices nationwide in navigating PBM audits, appeals, terminations, and related disputes. If your pharmacy or practice is facing an audit, adverse findings, network termination, or potential recoupment demand, contact Frier Levitt to speak with an attorney about your options.