Why Patient Communication Matters for Quality of Care and Risk Management
In today’s heavily regulated managed care environment, it’s easy to forget that patients are the very foundation of the health care profession. It’s no coincidence that both the growth of managed care and explosion of health care regulations have been accompanied by more patient complaints about uncaring providers who are allegedly “rude” and uncaring, make them wait for “hours” and often “rush” them out of the office. While it’s understandable that providers are distracted by the massive volume of administrative tasks and daunting responsibilities they face daily, focusing on patients is not only the key to effective health care but also to sound compliance and risk management.
Physicians are often under the mistaken belief that simply providing patients with the best medical treatment within the appropriate standard of care is enough to stay out of trouble. However, that is not necessarily true. The traditional term “bedside manner” has renewed importance in today’s health care environment. Patient complaints involving civility and communication can draw scrutiny from third-party payors, hospital administrators, licensing boards, and health care regulators, even when the underlying medical treatment meets the appropriate standard of care. Patients who are rushed, made to wait for inordinate amounts of time in the waiting room, or feel dismissed by their provider may raise concerns not only with the provider but also with their health insurer, state licensing board, or an attorney. For these reasons, proper civility and communication are skills that must be learned and maintained by every clinician.
Six Essential Patient Communication Practices for Health Care Providers
There are “rules of engagement” that apply to all professionals, whether or not they are employed within the health care space, when communicating with clients or patients. This code of conduct is consistent across professional settings and can help build trust when practiced regularly:
- Listen attentively before speaking.
- Ask questions.
- Set realistic expectations.
- Provide clear and honest responses.
- Allow clients or patients to vent or complain and validate their concerns, even when disagreeing with them.
- Demonstrate empathy and understanding.
Following these basic steps of communication will not only smooth interactions between providers and patients but also help prevent mistrust, miscommunication, or misunderstanding in the relationship. When providers establish trust with patients, patients are more likely to disclose their relevant health information, which in turn can enhance the quality of care while reducing the risk of lawsuits or other adverse actions.
As with any professional service, poor customer service leads to patient dissatisfaction, which can lead to negative ratings online or, worse, a complaint to a licensing board. All patients must feel as though every member of the practice team is looking out for their health and demonstrates genuine concern for their well-being. Having a friendly and compliant practice staff is an essential component of risk management. There are multiple ways to ensure that staff do not create unnecessary tension or conflict that could place the practice at risk.
Establish Professional Standards for Medical Practice Staff and Patient Interactions
One of the easiest ways to make patients feel put off is to allow staff members to gossip or discuss private information among themselves within earshot of patients, whether in a medical practice, hospital, or community clinic. Patients waiting for an appointment do not need to hear gossip or negative opinions about others. All conversations among staff should be task-related, professional, and respectful when around patients, without exception. Patient information must also be handled in accordance with applicable privacy and confidentiality requirements.
Serving on the “front line” of a medical practice, as a receptionist, nurse, or practice manager can be challenging. Patients, like customers or clients within any segment of the service industry, can be demanding, angry, and sometimes difficult to manage. Dealing with these types of patients is vexing and often requires considerable patience and skill. Medical office staff serve a vital purpose as the eyes and ears of the practice, as well as the “face” of the practice. No matter how many excuses a practice owner can muster for rude or unprofessional staff members, it is the licensee in charge of the practice who is ultimately responsible for the behavior of his or her employees.
Staff Training to Prevent Patient Complaints and Reduce Medical Practice Liability
Providers can take practical steps to assist staff in dealing with patients. Providing training on managing difficult patient encounters is a good step in the right direction. Customer service representatives may not naturally possess the patience and communication skills needed to handle challenging interactions. These skills can be developed through training, including simulated telephone conversations with individuals portraying difficult or frustrated patients. Through these exercises, they learn not to take abrasive behavior personally and to calmly and politely answer questions, no matter how enraged the caller may be. Practice staff must know that in this day and age, it is not unusual for patients to record telephone encounters. For that reason, staff should always assume that their interactions could be reviewed and maintain a professional demeanor at all times.
Overall, a well-trained, professional staff is an important first line of defense against legal and regulatory risks stemming from poor communication. Staff who can navigate cross-cultural, literacy, and language barriers are essential for any practice. When necessary, bilingual staff must be employed and utilized.
Maintaining Professional Boundaries in Physician-Patient Relationships
Health care providers are ethically bound to avoid relationships with patients that go beyond appropriate professional boundaries. The archive of licensing board actions contains a significant record of discipline against providers that stem from bad ethical judgment in the midst of a physician-patient romance. For psychiatrists and other mental health providers, such a boundary violation can spell the end of their medical career. Similarly, health care providers should avoid any financial relationships with patients, including loans, shared business interest, or employment arrangements. Gifts from patients should be discouraged, especially if a gift has monetary value and is given directly from the patient to the provider (rather than candy, cookies or cake brought in for the entire practice staff to enjoy). If a patient is providing special favors to the provider, whether monetary or romantic, the patient may expect to be treated accordingly, or more specifically, treated better than the provider’s other patients.
Recognizing Ethical Risks and Preventing Inappropriate Physician-Patient Relationships
There are many professional circumstances that can prompt the blurring of ethical lines. A patient’s romantic advances or significant events in a clinician’s personal life, such as trauma, transition, crisis, or loss, can create circumstances in which maintaining professional boundaries becomes more challenging. No matter what the cause, professional medical ethics guidelines consistently prohibit sexual relationships between physicians and their current patients. These types of relationships undermine physician objectivity, patient autonomy, and informed consent. This is why these relationships must be avoided. Treating a patient as a romantic partner or object of sexual desire compromises the fiduciary duty owed by the provider to the patient.
Reducing Patient Complaints, Licensing Board Risks, and Professional Liability Through Effective Communication
Avoiding negative reviews, licensing board complaints, and lawsuits starts with practice leadership. Whether working in a physician practice, not-for-profit clinic, or a hospital, civility and communication start from the top down, through leadership by example. Disruptive clinicians demonstrating angry outbursts, harsh words and uneven temperament are no longer tolerated by today’s patient population. Professionalism, empathy, and effective communication are essential skills that must be learned and maintained in the health care space. By establishing clear expectations for staff conduct, investing in communication training, and maintaining appropriate professional boundaries, health care providers can strengthen patient relationships while reducing legal, ethical, and regulatory risks.
How Frier Levitt Can Help
Frier Levitt advises physicians, medical practices, and other health care providers on regulatory compliance, professional conduct, and risk management. Our attorneys assist clients in developing policies and procedures to address patient complaints, staff conduct, and professional boundaries, as well as responding to licensing board investigations, disciplinary actions, and other regulatory matters. By taking a proactive approach to compliance and risk management, health care providers can better protect their practices, professional licenses, and patient relationships. Contact Frier Levitt to learn how our attorneys can help your practice navigate these legal and regulatory challenges.